[Case] ATO welcomes Federal Court decision against former EY tax partner

The ATO welcomes the Federal Court decision in Commissioner of Taxation v White.
The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) recognises the decision of the Federal Court in which former tax practitioner Mr Peter White was found liable under the Promoter Penalty Laws for promoting unlawful tax schemes to a number of his clients.
In 2023, the ATO lodged an application in the Federal Court seeking orders for the imposition of a civil penalty under Promoter Penalty Laws following an investigation.
The Court ruled that Mr White promoted unlawful tax schemes to clients and received consideration while setting up schemes for those clients.
The Court will determine the amount of penalty to be imposed in due course.
The decision may be subject to appeal and therefore, may be subject to further consideration by the Courts.
Promoter Penalty Laws are in place to deter and disrupt the promotion and implementation of aggressive tax avoidance and evasion schemes.
The promotion of tax exploitation schemes undermines the integrity of the tax and super system and challenges community trust and confidence. These schemes create an uneven playing field for everyone, including businesses and advisers.
The ATO uses Promoter Penalty Laws to take action against alleged promoters of tax exploitation schemes, regardless of the firm size, occupation, position in their organisation or standing in the tax community.
The ATO expects the utmost integrity of those providing advice in the tax system and will continue to take serious action against anyone who attempts to exploit or undermine the integrity of the tax system.
Commissioner of Taxation v White (Liability) [2026] FCA 1707
Court: Federal Court of Australia (Jackman J)
Judgment Date: 16 November 2026
Legislation: Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) (Promoter Penalty Laws)
Background & Facts
The Respondent: Peter Mark White, a Sydney-based former Ernst & Young (EY) tax partner and registered tax agent. (In May 2025, the Tax Practitioners Board terminated his registration and banned him for five years following findings of tax misconduct, including mischaracterising professional fees as "gifts" and failing to pay personal tax and GST liabilities.)
The Allegations: The Commissioner of Taxation brought civil penalty proceedings alleging that Mr White breached Australia's Promoter Penalty Laws. Specifically, the ATO alleged that he promoted a tax evasion scheme—or, alternatively, three separate tax exploitation schemes—to six individual clients across three distinct arrangements, receiving consideration for setting up those schemes.
Decision & Key Findings
Liability Established: Justice Jackman ruled in favour of the Commissioner, finding Mr White liable for promoting unlawful tax exploitation schemes to clients and receiving consideration for implementing them.
Next Steps (Quantum of Penalty): Because this judgment determined liability only, the Court has deferred determining the monetary amount of the civil penalties to a separate hearing.
Significance: The ATO welcomed the judgment as a landmark enforcement action demonstrating that Promoter Penalty Laws apply regardless of an adviser's seniority, firm size, or standing in the tax profession.
Source: ATO welcomes Federal Court decision against former EY tax partner | Australian Taxation Office, Commissioner of Taxation v White (Liability) [2026] FCA 1707
Disclaimer: This article is intended to provide general information only and does not constitute professional advice for specific circumstances. It should not be relied upon as a substitute for tailored advice.


![[Case] Taxpayer's "family gifts" are taxable](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/c42589_d63ee520a34a4a4c9042dd55ccff908a~mv2.webp/v1/fill/w_980,h_980,al_c,q_85,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,enc_avif,quality_auto/c42589_d63ee520a34a4a4c9042dd55ccff908a~mv2.webp)
Comments